The Corresponence of James McNeil Whistler
Home > On-line Edition > Transcription/Database Record

the on-line edition

System Number: 11395
Date: 28 September 1880
Author: Philip Gilbert Hamerton[1]
Place: Autun, France
Recipient: JW
Place: [Venice]
Repository: [Published][2]
Document Type: PLc

Mr Hamerton presents his compliments to Mr Whistler, and begs to inform him that he has read Mr Whistler's very unbecoming and improper letter[3] in the New York Tribune.

Mr Hamerton in his article in Scribner's Monthly simply quoted a passage from one of Mr Haden's lectures[4] on Etching, published in Cassell's Magazine of Art; consequently Mr Hamerton did not offer matter to his readers under any disguise whatever. Mr Hamerton has answered Mr Whistler's letter in the same journal in which it appeared.

Pré Charmoy, Autun, Saône et Loire

Sept. 28, 1880.

This document is protected by copyright.


1.  Philip Gilbert Hamerton
Philip Gilbert Hamerton (1834-1894), author, critic and artist [more].

2.  [Published]
Published in Whistler, James McNeill, The Gentle Art of Making Enemies, 2nd ed., London and New York, 1892, pp. 81-9.

3.  letter
See JW to the Editor, New York Tribune, #04281, letter dated 12 September 1880. This letter relates to a sequence of letters initiated by JW's response to Hamerton's article on F. S. Haden, which appeared in Scribner's Magazine in September 1880. It may have been a private reply to JW's letter of 12 September as another letter written by Hamerton to the New York Tribune also purports to be a reply (#11397). See also JW to P. G. Hamerton, #11396. Later, Haden joined the fray (see F. S. Haden to New York Tribune, 17 October 1880, p. 5).

4.  Mr Haden
Francis Seymour Haden (1818-1910), surgeon and etcher, JW's brother-in-law [more]. See 'Mr Seymour Haden on Etching,' Magazine of Art, December 1879, p. 262.