System Number: 00443
Date: 1 August 
Recipient: Committee of the Burlington Fine Arts Club
Repository: Glasgow University Library
Call Number: MS Whistler B222
Document Type: ALdS
2 Lindsey Row - Old Battersea bridge Chelsea -
In reply to your letter of the 31st of July, I have to say: that of course I have neither denied the punishment administered to Mr F. S. Haden, nor entered into any details concerning it, simply because I have yet to learn that the Committee of the Burlington Club have any right whatever to discuss that matter. - When that is once established I shall [p. 2] be charmed to relate, if it can be agreable [sic] to the Gentlemen, this, or any other little anecdote that shall possibly conduce to their amiable entertainment - Meanwhile the question at issue, is the conduct of the Committee towards myself - It has not as yet been made clear to me that any group, whose 'special' profession it is not, shall make it their 'custom always of an afternoon', to discuss the private affairs of a gentleman and entertain any information respecting him - and having taken [p. 3] upon themselves to treat this gentleman with marked want of courtesy, should conceive it possible to maintain this peculiar pursuit or drop it at their pleasure! -
I have, Gentlemen
the honor to be
Your obedient servant
J A McNeill Whistler
To the Gentlemen of the Committee of the Burlington Club -
[p. 4] I have therefore the honor
to dir again to direct the attention of the Committee to the fact that my letters of the 14th and 25th of June remain substantially unanswered.
1. 1 August 
Year dated from the subject matter of the Burlington Club dispute (see below).
2. Committee of the Burlington Fine Arts Club
The Burlington Club was a club for artists and connoisseurs. It was founded in c. June 1866 and located at 177 Piccadilly. Its committee included William Boxall (1800-1879), portrait painter, Director of the National Gallery [more]; Louis Huth (1821-1905), collector [more]; Richard Fisher (d. 1890), Fellow and Curator of the Society of Painter-Etchers [more]; Vittorio Emanuelle Taparelli (1816-1890), Marquis D'Azeglio, Sardinian Ambassador and collector [more] (President); and Ralph Nicholson Wornum (1812-1877), history painter [more] (Secretary).
3. 2 Lindsey ... Chelsea -
The address is crossed through by two diagonal lines.
5. Mr F. S. Haden
Francis Seymour Haden (1818-1910), surgeon and etcher, JW's brother-in-law [more]. The 'punishment' referred to by JW relates to his quarrel with Haden over his treatment of James Reeves Traer (ca 1834 - d.1867), partner in F. S. Haden's medical practice [more]. Traer died suddenly on 23 April 1867 of alcohol related causes, during a trip to Paris. Haden arranged for Traer's burial with what JW and his brother William regarded as unseemly haste. On 26 April, a violent row took place between the brothers-in-law in a Paris café and Haden fell (or allegedly was pushed by JW) through a plate glass window. Both JW and Haden were members of the Burlington Club. Soon after the incident, Haden, a committee member, campaigned for JW to be excluded from the club, citing as evidence the Paris incident but also bringing to its attention several previous alleged incidents of assault (see JW to L. Huth, #02240).
On 11 June, JW was asked to resign his membership on the threat of expulsion (see R. N. Wornum to JW, #10442). Aggrieved by the summary way in which he felt the Club had treated him, JW refused to entertain the charges against him, claiming the Club had no right to interfere in a private matter (see JW to L. Huth, #02240). He wrote to William Boxall and Louis Huth in protest: 'For some time back the members of the Committee have been accepting continual relays of information and collecting documents which as I now find involve even enclosures from utter strangers on my personal affairs! - And yet at an advanced stage of this elaborate system, the first notification which I receive, actually takes the form of an unmodified request to withdraw from the club at the risk of expulsion!!' (see JW to Burlington Fine Arts Club Committee, #00401)